South Pacific Sandy Island 'proven not to exist'

 Sandy ghost island with 2008 SHOM nautical map (7321/INT636)

SHOM ENC
overlayed on Google Maps with transparency

>>> geolocalization with the Marine GeoGarage <<<

 From BBC

Sandy island undiscovered

A South Pacific island, shown on marine charts and world maps as well as on Google Earth, does not exist, Australian scientists say.

Google Earth view

but also found in satellite imagery view of Nokia Maps or map view of Bing Maps 
using NASA Blue Marble imagery

The supposedly sizeable strip of land, named Sandy Island on Google Maps, was positioned midway between Australia and French-governed New Caledonia.

Neither the French government - the invisible island would sit within French territorial waters if it existed - nor the ship's nautical charts, which are based on depth measurements, had the island marked on their maps.
>>> geolocalization with the Marine GeoGarage <<< 

 extract of chart 5978 from SHOM (French Hydrographic Office)
no 'île Sable' in 1982 

 Nouvelle Calédonie SHOM ENC official vector chart FR273210 (scale : 1:1,500,000)
(other view with depths in meters)
no 'île Sable' in 2012 update

But when scientists from the University of Sydney went to the area, they found only the blue ocean of the Coral Sea.

The phantom island has featured in publications for at least a decade.

from Columbia encyclopedia

Scientist Maria Seton, who was on the ship, said that the team was expecting land, not 1,400m (4,620ft) of deep ocean.

"We wanted to check it out because the navigation charts on board the ship showed a water depth of 1,400m in that area - very deep," Dr Seton, from the University of Sydney, told the AFP news agency after the 25-day voyage.

"It's on Google Earth and other maps so we went to check and there was no island. We're really puzzled. It's quite bizarre.

"How did it find its way onto the maps? We just don't know, but we plan to follow up and find out."

Atlas map : Australian, N.Z. ports (British map 1922) 

(David Rumsey Historical Map Collection)
with 'Sandy island' indication

 Soviet Union atlas map (1967)

(David Rumsey collection)
with shoal indication instead of fictional 'Sandy island'

see other ancient maps from Rumsey collection on :
Maps of Sandy Island Through History
the non-existent "Sandy Island" has been drawn (or not) in some maps since the 1770's,
so long before the arrival of satellite imagery

Karte von Australien oder Polynesien, nach den Zeichnungen Reisebeschreibungen und Tagebücher der vorzüglichsten Seefahrer bis 1789 entworffen im Jahr 1792 (Gallica BNF)
(note : the existence of another 'Sandy island' in the North of New Caledonia island) 

NGA chart 56 Great circle sailing chart of the North Pacific Ocean

(edition sept 1973)

with shoal indication instead of fictional 'Sandy island'

 Ocean ArcGIS Basemap (ESRI) and also in Natural Earth II
with 'Sandy island'

New Caledonia and Vanuatu bathymetric and topographic map
with 'Ile de Sable' 
(also in GeoPortail overview)

 C-Map CM93/2 (2009) commercial vector map view on OpenCPN software
with 'Sandy island'

Navionics (2012) commercial vector map online view
with 'Sandy Island'

 Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea bathymetry
in Google Earth (kmz) / e-Atlas
   with 'Sandy island'

Australian newspapers have reported that the invisible island would sit within French territorial waters if it existed - but does not feature on French government maps.

Sandy island from the GSHHS worldwide high-resolution shoreline data set (QGIS view)

Mike Prince, the director of charting services for the Australian Hydrographic Service, a department within the Navy that produces the country’s official nautical charts,
said the world coastline database incorporated individual reports that were sometimes old or contained errors.

 Sandy island in the VMAP-0 vector map file,
available from NGA
next version of widely used Digital Chart of the World (DCW)
also found in weather satellite picture (GOES NOAA)

 Global gravity (kmz) on Google Earth in the area of the supposed 'Sandy island'
(ref : Sandwell, D. T., and W. H. F. Smith,
Global marine gravity from retracked Geosat and ERS-1 altimetry)

Measured and estimated seafloor topography (STRM30+) kmz by Google Earth
(ref : Smith, W. H. F., and D. T. Sandwell, Global seafloor topography
from satellite altimetry and ship depth soundings)
which has been directly used by Google or GEBCO (General Bathymetric Chart of the Oceans)

Australia's Hydrographic Service, which produces the country's nautical charts, says its appearance on some scientific maps and Google Earth could just be the result of human error, repeated down the years.

A spokesman from the service told Australian newspapers that while some map makers intentionally include phantom streets to prevent copyright infringements, that was was not usually the case with nautical charts because it would reduce confidence in them.
Mike Prince, the director of charting services for the Australian Hydrographic Service, a department within the Navy, said that while some map-makers added non-existent streets in order to keep tabs on people stealing their data, that was not standard practice with nautical charts.
“[That would] reduce confidence in what is actually correct,” he said.

A spokesman for Google Earth said they consult a variety of authoritative sources when making their maps.

"The world is a constantly changing place, the spokesman told AFP, "and keeping on top of these changes is a never-ending endeavour'.'

 indication of 'Sandy island' (discovered by 'Velocity' whaling ship 1876 -photos-) on : 
Australia Coral Sea and Great Barrier Reefs

shewing the Inner and Outer routes to Torres Strait,

compiled chiefly from the Surveys of Captains Flinders, King, Blackwood, Stanley, Yule & Denham

RN 1802-60 with additions from Admiralty surveys in progress to 1888

Published at the Admiralty Decr. 19th 1860 under the Superintendence of Capt. Washington, R.N., F.R.S. Hydrographer

(see National Library of Australia)

indication of 'Sandy island' on

Neue Karte von Australien / von prof Fr. Behr -J. Maier (Stuttgart)-1888

(BNF Gallica)

not any indication of 'Sandy island' on
Brue, A.H., Levasseur, E. Australie, Nouvelle-Zelande. 1875 World Atlas

David Rumsey collection

Other ancient maps (BNF Gallica) :

• Carte de l'Océanie contenant l'Australie, la Polynésie et les Iles Asiatiques Par J.B. Poirson, Ing. Géog. Revue par A.Toussaint -Vve. Turgis (Paris)-1832
• General-Karte von Australien, Friedrich H. Handtke, 1889

  neither on :

ORSTOM bathymetry map 1979  (other bathy maps 1981 / 1987) 

 neither on Transas map

 neither on :
PlanetObserver Landsat satellite imagery (15m) (IGN GeoPortail view)

neither on :
http://explorateur-carto.georep.nc 
or http://carto.gouv.nc (on Google Earth : kmz)
with bathymetric data from SHOM multibeam echo-sounder surveys in 2008
(IRD 'Alis' ship with Simrad EM1002 and IFREMER 'Atalante' ship with Simrad EM12,
isobaths ZEE NC file -pdf map-
surveys tracks SHOM + IFREMER + IRD)

neither on :
Lansat satellite view on the area (or on Glovis USGS)

The BBC's Duncan Kennedy in Sydney says that while most explorers dream of discovering uncharted territory, the Australian team appears to have done the opposite - and cartographers everywhere are now rushing to un-discover Sandy Island for ever.

Links :

• SydneyMorningHerald :  Where did it go? Scientists 'undiscover' Pacific island
• Wikipedia / Talk
• blog GeoGarage : Lost Islands: the story of Islands that have vanished from nautical charts 

Tropical reefs become biggest US Marine Sanctuary

Map of National Marine Sanctuary of American Samoa, America's largest marine sanctuary.

>>> geolocalization with the Marine GeoGarage <<<

From OurAmazingPlanet
 
A pristine tropical reef that has weathered several natural disasters is now part of America's largest marine sanctuary.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) finalized a huge expansion of the Fagatele Bay National Marine Sanctuary in American Samoa last month, from 0.25 square miles (0.65 square kilometers) to 13,523 square miles (33,024 square km).
The boost takes the sanctuary from a single protected coral reef to a marine area larger than the state of Maryland. The agency also renamed the protected region, now calling it the National Marine Sanctuary of American Samoa.

Five new marine units joined Fagatale Bay's reef: Fogama'a/ Fagalua (Larsen Bay), waters around Swains Island and Muliva, also known as Rose Atoll, and some of the waters around Aunu'u Island and Ta'u Island.

NOAA cited the "tremendous advancement in marine discovery and exploration, marine conservation science, and ecosystem-based management" as factors in its decision to expand the sanctuary.
The decision was published July 26 and finalized Oct. 31 in the Federal Register.
"The Sanctuary contains a unique and vast array of tropical marine organisms, including corals and a diverse tropical reef ecosystem with endangered and threatened species, such as the hawksbill and green sea turtles, and marine mammals like the Pacific bottlenose dolphin," NOAA said in the Federal Register.
Of the five new units, one was already under federal protection.

Rose Atoll was designated a marine national monument in 2009 by President George W. Bush.
It is the world's smallest atoll, and home to American Samoa's largest populations of giant clams, nesting seabirds and rare reef fish.

photo Cristy Weggelaar

Ta'u Island hosts some of the oldest and largest known corals in the world, with one colony measuring 23 feet (7 meters) tall and 135 feet (41 m) in circumference, according to NOAA.
And from June to September, southern humpback whales migrate north from Antarctica to calve in the protected waters surrounding American Samoa.

Fagatele Bay National Marine Sanctuary was established in 1986 in response to a proposal from the American Samoa government.
The impetus was a devastating attack on the region's coral reefs by crown-of-thorns starfish in the late 1970s. Millions of starfish ate their way across the reefs, destroying more than 90 percent of living coral. Hurricanes and coral bleaching have also hit the coral in the last 20 years.

NASA: Antarctic sea ice grows – but the climate’s still changing

Sheldon Glacier, Antarctica with Mount Barre in background,
from Ryder Bay near Rothera Research Station, Adelaide Island.

A new study examines why Antarctic sea ice cover has increased under the effects of climate change over the past two decades.

From TheDigitalJournal

A NASA study has reported a rise in Antarctic sea ice.
For cherry picking climate change deniers, it may be a neat counterweight to Arctic ice melt but, as the NASA study shows, Antarctic ice expansion is another worrying trend in global climate change.

The principal finding of the new NASA study, conducted in conjunction with the British Antarctic Study, relates to a significant growth in Antarctic sea ice drift caused by changes in the wind currents around Antarctica observed over the past twenty years.
Changes in wind currents can arise due to an alteration in underlying sea temperatures and it is here that the rapid ice loss seen in the Arctic Ocean may be reconciled with what would appear, at first glance, to be conflicting data from the Antarctic.

The sea ice in the Arctic Ocean dropped below the previous all-time record set in 2007.

This year also marks the first time that there has been less than 4 million square kilometers (1.54 million square miles) of sea ice since satellite observations began in 1979.

This animation shows the 2012 time-series of ice extent using sea ice concentration data from the DMSP SSMI/S satellite sensor.

The black area represents the daily average (median) sea ice extent over the 1979-2000 time period.

Layered over top of that are the daily satellite measurements from January 1 -- September 14, 2012.

A rapid melt begins in July, whereby the 2012 ice extents fall far below the historical average.

The National Snow and Ice Data Center will confirm the final minimum ice extent data and area once the melt stabilizes, usually in mid-September.

In mid-October Digital Journal reported on the record ice melt of Arctic sea ice observed by NASA which now has comparative data on the Arctic polar ice cap dating back almost 35 years.
According to NASA and the British Antarctic Survey, the expansion of Antarctic sea ice is but another facet of climate change, connected to rather than conflicting with the opposite effect observed in the Arctic.
Using maps created by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) which have been built up from five million individual daily measurements of the flows of sea ice around the Antarctic continent, research scientists Ron Kwok of JPL and Paul Holland of the Natural Environment Research Council's British Antarctic Survey, Cambridge, United Kingdom have constructed a model to illustrate what is happening in the Antarctic.
For the first time, researchers have been able to show long term changes in the Antarctic sea ice over a period of almost two decades using data collected by four U.S. Defense Meteorological satellites.
Said Holland, the principal author of the report recently published in Nature Geosciences,

“Until now these changes in ice drift were only speculated upon, using computer models of Antarctic winds. This study of direct satellite observations shows the complexity of climate change. The total Antarctic sea-ice cover is increasing slowly, but individual regions are actually experiencing much larger gains and losses that are almost offsetting each other overall. We now know that these regional changes are caused by changes in the winds, which in turn affect the ice cover through changes in both ice drift and air temperature. The changes in ice drift also suggest large changes in the ocean surrounding Antarctica, which is very sensitive to the cold and salty water produced by sea-ice growth.
“Sea ice is constantly on the move; around Antarctica the ice is blown away from the continent by strong northward winds. Since 1992 this ice drift has changed. In some areas the export of ice away from Antarctica has doubled, while in others it has decreased significantly.”

It is significant that whereas the headline figure is reporting a growth in Antarctic sea ice, Holland refers to this being a two-way flow with expansion of sea ice in some areas being offset by losses of ice elsewhere in seas around Antarctica.
The northward drift of sea ice could help explain extremes of sea ice growth in some areas of the Southern Ocean around the Antarctic continent by means of a cooling feedback reaction.
Sea ice, being white, is highly reflective of the sun’s rays whilst dark sea water in liquid form absorbs heat from the sun.
Thus, expanding sea ice can cause a cooling effect encouraging the formation of more sea ice around itself.
The reflective qualities of sea ice means that it plays a significant role in Earth’s environment, not only reflecting heat from the sun back into space but forming a niche habitat for a variety of marine species.
At both the North and South polar regions, sea ice reaches its minimum in late summer after months when the polar regions are bathed in 24 hour sunlight.
In the Arctic, however, the trend for these summer sea ice minima has been inexorably downwards, so much so that scientists now predict that the Arctic Ocean will be free of sea ice during the summer before the end of the 21st century.
During Antarctica’s winter freeze, sea ice generally expands and covers an area of the ocean around the polar continent approximately twice the size of Europe.
The sea ice, as well as reflecting sunlight, also acts as a blanket insulating the relatively warm seawater beneath from the sub zero temperatures in the air above.
Again, changes in the sea ice, with its reflective and insulating qualities, are likely to have unpredictable consequences for the Antarctic continent and, flowing from that, climate change globally.
JPL/British Antarctic Survey says the new study helps in understanding why there should be such a contrast between the two polar regions when it comes to sea ice.
While the Arctic appears to be melting at an accelerating rate, over the period of the study, Antarctic sea ice in toto has actually increased, albeit slightly.
The researchers state, however, that the slight net Antarctic increase in sea ice hides the underlying story of large regional increases and decreases, significant localised changes which are wind-driven. The different topography of the Arctic Ocean and Antarctica also provides some clues as to what is happening, scientists say.
Whereas the Arctic Ocean is, to all intends and purposes, surrounded by land so that wind flows cannot cause Arctic ice to expand in the same way, in Antarctica and the Southern Ocean, northward winds, blowing off the continent, can force sea ice to ‘flow’ northwards as there are no land or continental barriers to halt the flow.
Highlighting how any localised expansion of Antarctic sea ice cannot be seen in isolation, Ron Kwok of JPL says,

“The Antarctic sea ice cover interacts with the global climate system very differently than that of the Arctic, and these results highlight the sensitivity of the Antarctic ice coverage to changes in the strength of the winds around the continent."

Wind driven flows of sea ice around Antarctica

NASA- JPL/ British Antarctic Survey

 From the National Snow and Ice Data Center:

Animated map of 2012 sea ice extent shown side-by-side with 1979--2009 climatology.

The NASA/British Antarctic Survey report emphasises that it focused on sea ice flows and formation around the Antarctic which has to be distinguished from the land-based Antarctic Ice Sheet, glacial ice, which continues to lose volume.

Although not touched on by the report, the wind induced changes in sea ice formation around the Antarctic could result in some glacial ice which would otherwise be ‘locked-in’ by sea ice, tending to calf icebergs which might not otherwise have floated off from the continental ice sheet.

Elsewhere, expansion of sea ice could have as yet unforeseen localised effects on the climate.

As with all climate change studies and models, due to the timescales involved in assembling meaningful data, knowing what may happen is fraught with difficulty whilst unfulfilled predictions merely serve to provide ammunition to those who would hold that climate change is a myth.

The NASA/British Antarctic Survey study does not attempt to predict what the future may hold, but, just as it is unnecessary to count the spots on a leopard to identify it as a big cat, the study is yet another indication that climate change is here and now, even if some politicians think it’s a pussycat.

1650 Jansson Wind Rose, Anemographic Chart, or Map of the Winds

Tabula anemographica seu Pyxis Nautica : ventorum nomina sex linguis repraesentans

(zoom version from BNF Gallica)

From Geographicus 

An exceptionally rare example of one of the earliest and most significant anemographic, or wind rose, charts to appear in the 17th century.
This unusual chart represents a transitional point in the perception of direction, or to be precise, the transition from the wind rose to the compass rose.

Early mariners in the Mediterranean defined direction by the names the various winds and the points from which they blew.
This idea traces its roots to ancient Greece.
Homer identified four cardinal winds, but as navigation and cartography advanced, more were added. This chart represents a full thirty-two named winds and a multitude of different wind systems.
Each of the winds is identified by several different names in Greek, Latin, French, and Dutch.
Each wind is additionally attached to both contemporary compass points, north west east and south, and a more sophisticated circle and degree system.
In the areas surrounding the sphere, each wind is personified by a figure bearing the racial characteristics associated with the region or direction represented.
The upper left quadrant, representing north, depicts bearded Germans or Scandinavians.
The upper right, representing east, shows beardless dark skinned faces.
The beardless and pale skinned figures in the lower left and right, representing west and south, are less distinguishable but may be intended to represent indigenous Americans and Greeks.

Anemographic charts, like this, were functional objects and valuable reference tools.
Early navigators, referring to the directions as winds, might "sail by the north wind".
This was exceptionally practical when trade winds dictated ocean commerce.
A warm wind from the south, for example might suggest that certain routes, closed for part of the year, were now open.
A navigator would have used this chart to compare different names for directions.
So, he may be using a chart made in Greece that identified the winds by the names of Greek gods, but himself been trained to use to a different, say Catalan or English, nomenclature.
With this chart, he could figure out what various sailing logs and navigation books were referring to. Remember, while nautical charts did exist in the 1600s, most navigation was accomplished using "Pilot Books" that had instructions like this "follow the south wind for 3 days before turning with the eastern wind" etc.
Thus this was a very useful object indeed.

This chart was published as plate 1 in Jansonnius' 1650 Atlas Maritimus or volume 5 in his Atlantis Majoris

Incredible image that reveals dust, salt and smoke in the Earth's atmosphere - and supercomputer that made it could improve weather forecasting

The extinction optical thickness of aerosols from a free running 10-km GEOS-5 Nature-Run including dust (red), sea salt (blue), black and organic carbon (green) and sulphate (white) are depicted from August 2006 through April 2007.

GEOS-5 was run with the GOCART model providing feedbacks of the direct radiative effects of aerosols within the model in addition to their advection by the weather within the simulation.
Sea-salt (blue) is churned up from the ocean based on surface wind speeds, and most prevalent along mid-latitude storm tracks and frontal regions (including the Southern Ocean) and within the circulation and eye of tropical cyclones.

Dust (red) is most prominent over the Saharan desert and can be seen interacting with a few Atlantic tropical cyclones during the end of the 2006 Atlantic hurricane season.

Organic and black carbon (green) are dispensed into the atmosphere from biomass burning, the most prominent for this period being over South America from Aug-Oct 2006, Indonesia from Sept-Nov 2006, Africa in January 2007.

Sulphate (white) can be seen from two primary sources, those being fossil fuel emissions over Asia, Europe and the US, and also from volcanic emissions, there is a persistently active volcanic emission from Mt Nyiragongo in Mozambique Africa, and then a large eruption from the Karthala Volcano on Grand Comore Island, Comoros in January of 2007.

From DailyMail

It is an astonishing view of the Earth that reveals just what is in the atmosphere.
This image, released by Nasa, was created by a supercomputer designed to model aerosols in the Earth's atmosphere.
It shows how dust, sea salt, smoke and sulphates travel - and could dramatically improve weather forecasts.

(Image: William Putman, NASA/Goddard Earth Observing System Model
GEOS-5 full resolution)

The Nasa image shows aerosols in the atmosphere.

Dust (red) is lifted from the surface, sea salt (blue) swirls inside cyclones, smoke (green) rises from fires, and sulfate particles (white) stream from volcanoes and fossil fuel emissions.

The high-resolution global atmospheric modeling was done using the Discover supercomputer at the NASA Center for Climate Simulation at Goddard Space Flight Center in Maryland.

Nasa said the facility 'provides a unique tool to study the role of weather in Earth's climate system.

 

Goddard Space Flight Center is the home of a state-of-the-art supercomputing facility called the NASA Center for Climate Simulation (NCCS) that is capable of running highly complex models to help scientists better understand Earth's climate.

This short video introduces the NCCS and takes you behind-the-scenes into the fascinating field of climate modeling.

Using supercomputers to process data from satellite observations, these models are used to predict weather and give a picture of how the Earth's systems and climate are changing.

The Goddard Earth Observing System Model, Version 5 (GEOS-5) is capable of simulating worldwide weather at resolutions of 10 to 3.5 kilometers (km).
This portrait of global aerosols was produced by a GEOS-5 simulation at a 10-kilometer resolution.
Dust (red) is lifted from the surface, sea salt (blue) swirls inside cyclones, smoke (green) rises from fires, and sulfate particles (white) stream from volcanoes and fossil fuel emissions.

Dust, in red, swirls over Europe, while close to the Australian coast, sea salt (blue) is clearly visible

The supercomputer has previously been used to recreate major weather events, such as this image of the humidity on June 17, 1993, during the Great Flood that hit the Midwestern United States