Matthew island with the GeoGarage platform (SHOM nautical raster chart)From OpinionNigeria by Fransiscus Nanga Roka
Both countries have a responsibility to release the colonial maps and government documents that each base its claims upon.
Each country must also invite indigenous leaders of southern Vanuatu and New Caledonia to provide testimony as to the terms of their people’s approval.
A fishing crew should be able to present the same chart and regulatory guidelines to a law enforcement official of either country during the time that each country’s legal representatives present their respective arguments.

In Paris during May, the Group of Seven (G7) countries, including France, reiterated that the 2016 South China Sea ruling applies to both China and the Philippines.
France should provide the International Court of Justice (ICJ) with written permission to consider the dispute between Vanuatu and New Caledonia regarding two disputed Pacific Islands and the maritime boundary with New Caledonia.
France should also pursue a separate arbitration proceeding against the surrounding waters.
France should provide the International Court of Justice (ICJ) with written permission to consider the dispute between Vanuatu and New Caledonia regarding two disputed Pacific Islands and the maritime boundary with New Caledonia.
France should also pursue a separate arbitration proceeding against the surrounding waters.
In Vanuatu History, particularly Aneityum, the two islands have names.
Umaenupne (Matthew Island): Also referred to as Leka (the island of the legendary figure Mauitikitiki).
Umaeneg (Hunter Island): Also historically referred to as Fanumanu, which translates to the "island of pigeons".
Umaenupne (Matthew Island): Also referred to as Leka (the island of the legendary figure Mauitikitiki).
Umaeneg (Hunter Island): Also historically referred to as Fanumanu, which translates to the "island of pigeons".
Matthew and Hunter are uninhabited volcanic islands located to the east of New Caledonia.
In Vanuatu, these two islands are referred to as Umaenupne and Umaeneg, with the second island often referred to as Leka.
These two islands are considered sacred by several communities in southern Vanuatu.
From 1906 until 1980, the New Hebrides were under the joint administration of Britain and France.
When the New Hebrides gained independence from Britain in 1980, it took the name Vanuatu.
The islands are administered by France as part of New Caledonia.
In 1975, France placed sovereignty plaques on both islands.
However, Vanuatu claims that the islands were included within the borders of the territory that it received when it achieved independence.
On August 31, Vanuatu applied to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for a decision regarding sovereignty and a single maritime boundary between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.
This application was made pursuant to an ICJ provision which allows the court to hear a case once France agrees.
Deputy Prime Minister Johnny Koanapo stated to Parliament earlier this month that France has yet to agree to the ICJ proceeding.
On October 23, Vanuatu initiated a different type of arbitration through the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
The purpose of this arbitration is to determine whether Matthew, Hunter, Walpole and surrounding reef systems are considered “islands” as defined by UNCLOS.
In Vanuatu, these two islands are referred to as Umaenupne and Umaeneg, with the second island often referred to as Leka.
These two islands are considered sacred by several communities in southern Vanuatu.
From 1906 until 1980, the New Hebrides were under the joint administration of Britain and France.
When the New Hebrides gained independence from Britain in 1980, it took the name Vanuatu.
The islands are administered by France as part of New Caledonia.
In 1975, France placed sovereignty plaques on both islands.
However, Vanuatu claims that the islands were included within the borders of the territory that it received when it achieved independence.
On August 31, Vanuatu applied to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for a decision regarding sovereignty and a single maritime boundary between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.
This application was made pursuant to an ICJ provision which allows the court to hear a case once France agrees.
Deputy Prime Minister Johnny Koanapo stated to Parliament earlier this month that France has yet to agree to the ICJ proceeding.
On October 23, Vanuatu initiated a different type of arbitration through the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
The purpose of this arbitration is to determine whether Matthew, Hunter, Walpole and surrounding reef systems are considered “islands” as defined by UNCLOS.
Article 121 enables those islands that meet certain criteria to have their own exclusive economic zones that may extend as far out as 200 nautical miles from their shores, as well as have rights on the continental shelf.
On the other hand, rocks that are unable to support human life or an economy will be allowed to establish up to 12 nautical miles of territorial sea.
Reefs that are only visible at low tide will also be able to assist in defining a territorial sea, provided they are in proximity to an island or mainland.
These differences will determine which governments will be able to issue permits for fishing and exploration of the seabed.
France has decided not to submit itself to compulsory adjudication of its maritime boundaries pursuant to Article 298 of the Convention.
In 2016, the South China Sea Tribunal considered the maritime rights created by disputed features in the South China Sea, but did not rule on either the issue of sovereignty or the boundary itself.
Therefore, the arbitrators in Vanuatu’s case will need to determine if they are able to proceed with their decision-making process in a similar manner.
Additionally, Annex VII to the Convention provides that proceedings may continue even if one of the parties is not present.
Prior to ruling in favor of Vanuatu, the tribunal must first find that it possesses jurisdiction over the matter and then assess the validity of Vanuatu’s claims based upon the available evidence and applicable law.
It would be advisable for France to attend the hearing so that any jurisdictional arguments can be made part of the official record.
France and Vanuatu agreed in July 2025 that they would attempt to negotiate an agreement.
Their negotiators are expected to produce a map of the overlapping claims and suspend any further fishing or seabed concessions within the overlapping areas within 90 days.
A new concession provides its owner with a monetary interest in protecting the position of one government.
Agree on maximum allowable catches from currently operational fisheries, exchange data regarding inspections and create a hotline to report incidents occurring at sea.
The interim agreement must clearly protect the legal positions of both nations.
US Navy (1901 chart)
Both countries have a responsibility to release the colonial maps and government documents that each base its claims upon.
Each country must also invite indigenous leaders of southern Vanuatu and New Caledonia to provide testimony as to the terms of their people’s approval.
A fishing crew should be able to present the same chart and regulatory guidelines to a law enforcement official of either country during the time that each country’s legal representatives present their respective arguments.
Links :
Each country must also invite indigenous leaders of southern Vanuatu and New Caledonia to provide testimony as to the terms of their people’s approval.
A fishing crew should be able to present the same chart and regulatory guidelines to a law enforcement official of either country during the time that each country’s legal representatives present their respective arguments.
Links :
- Al Jazeera : Vanuatu takes France to ICJ over Matthew and Hunter islands dispute
- Inside Story : Drawing a line in the ocean
- Vanuatu Daily Post : “Our journey to Independence is not yet complete”: PM reaffirms Vanuatu’s fight for Umaenupne and Umaeneg
- Island Business : Vanuatu takes Matthew and Hunter dispute to ICJ
- LNC : Matthew et Hunter : aux origines d’une souveraineté disputée




.jpg)




Turquoise shallows glow against the deep blue sea in this view of the Caribbean from Sentinel-3C on 29 September, with Cuba to the south and the Bahamas to the north.